The Artists Who Shaped My Songwriting — And What Each One Actually Taught Me

Nobody develops a voice in isolation.

Every songwriter you have ever admired absorbed an enormous amount of music before they made the music that made you pay attention to them. The influences are always there. In the chord choices, in the melodic instincts, in the decisions about where a lyric goes direct and where it reaches for something oblique. A songwriter's catalog is partly a map of everything they loved before they learned to say something of their own.

I want to give you the honest version of that map for me. Not a list of names dropped for credibility. The specific thing each artist taught me, embedded in the music I make as Tony Oso, that I can point to directly and say: that came from listening to this person for years.

This is also a post for anyone trying to develop their own voice as a songwriter. Because the way you develop a voice is by being honest about the voices that shaped you and then doing the work of finding what is yours within and underneath that influence. You cannot shortcut the influence. You can be deliberate about understanding what it gave you.


TOM PETTY — ECONOMY AND TRUTH

Tom Petty is the first influence I want to name because he is the most fundamental. I grew up in Florida. Tom Petty was from Gainesville. I attended school in Gainesville. There was a specific inevitability to his music being part of the soundtrack of growing up in this state that I did not fully appreciate until I was old enough to understand how rare what he was doing actually was.

What Petty taught me is economy. The discipline to say the most with the least. His songs almost never have a word or a chord that is not necessary and almost never reach for complexity when simplicity will do the job more effectively. I Won't Back Down is three chords and eight words in the title line and it is one of the most complete statements of resolve in the American rock canon. That compression, the willingness to trust that the simple version is the powerful version, is something I work toward in every song I write.

He also taught me truth in the vernacular. Petty wrote about real places, real feelings, real American life, in language that was never elevated beyond what the moment required. The characters in his songs live in recognizable circumstances. The emotions are ones you have felt. He never reached for poetry when plain speech would reach the person listening more directly.

Tom Petty appears throughout The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips and The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time.


BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN — THE WEIGHT OF SPECIFICITY

Springsteen is the master of the specific detail that opens into the universal. The way he names a town, a car, a highway, a particular quality of light at a particular time of day, and uses those concrete particulars to carry an emotional weight that is anything but particular.

What he taught me is that specificity is not limitation. It is the opposite of limitation. The more precisely you locate a feeling in a specific circumstance, the more universally recognizable that feeling becomes. A song about loss in the abstract reaches no one fully. A song about loss at a specific moment, in a specific place, with a specific person, reaches everyone who has ever lost anything because the precision creates the recognition.

I brought that lesson into songs like Going Down, which is not about addiction as a concept but about specific people I watched in a specific window of time heading somewhere specific. The concreteness of the reference is what gives the song its reach. The listener does not need to know the specific people. They recognize the specific feeling because the song is precise about it.

Springsteen also taught me that a song can hold darkness and forward motion simultaneously. His best songs do not resolve the darkness into easy hope. They move through it with momentum. The character is not saved. The character keeps going. That is a different and more honest kind of inspiration and it is the version I try to write.

Springsteen appears in The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time and The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips.


GOO GOO DOLLS — THE COURAGE OF VULNERABILITY

I have shared a stage with the Goo Goo Dolls. Seeing their songs in a live room, watching how the audience responds to them, changed my understanding of what vulnerability in songwriting actually does for the people listening.

John Rzeznik writes from an exposed place. The emotions in Goo Goo Dolls songs are not armored. They are right on the surface, which in the context of rock music in the 1990s and 2000s was a genuine act of creative courage. And the response from audiences is the response that exposed, honest songwriting always produces: recognition that feels personal.

What they taught me is that the rock framework, the electric guitars and the full band arrangement and the volume, does not require emotional armor to function. The loudness can carry the vulnerability rather than covering it. In fact the contrast between the emotional exposure of the lyric and the physical force of the music amplifies both. The song is harder and more direct for the combination.

That lesson is in the Tony Oso catalog throughout. Songs like Tears use the rock framework to carry emotional content that the genre does not always go toward. The willingness to go there, to be exposed within the loud arrangement, came from years of listening to the Goo Goo Dolls do it.

Goo Goo Dolls appear in The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips.


PEARL JAM — COMMITMENT AS A PERFORMANCE QUALITY

Eddie Vedder's vocal performances are some of the most committed in the history of rock music. When he is in a song he is completely in it. There is no distance between the performer and the material. He is not presenting the song. He is inside it.

What Pearl Jam taught me is that commitment is a performance quality that the listener can feel and that its absence is equally audible. When a performer is holding something back, when there is a gap between the emotion the song is supposed to carry and the emotion the performer is actually accessing, the listener feels that gap even when they cannot name it. The song feels unearned.

I brought that lesson into how I approach live performance. A 4-hour show is a test of that commitment across a duration that shorter sets do not demand. The question is not whether you can be fully committed for the first forty-five minutes. The question is whether you can be fully committed in hour three when the fatigue is present and the adrenaline is gone. Pearl Jam's performances at their best answer that question in a way that has shaped how I understand what being on stage is supposed to cost.

Pearl Jam appears in The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time, The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips, and The Best Skate Punk and Indie Rock Songs of All Time. The commitment question is addressed directly in What Playing 4-Hour Live Sets Taught Me That No Music School Ever Could.


SISTER HAZEL — THE WARMTH THAT EARNS THE WEIGHT

Sister Hazel are one of the most underappreciated bands in the American rock canon and their influence on my songwriting is specific and real.

They understand warmth in a way that a lot of rock bands do not go for. The production of their records, the vocal harmonies, the guitar tones, the arrangements, all of it is warm in a way that is not soft. Warm and soft are not the same thing. Warmth in a song means that the listener feels welcomed into it before the emotional weight arrives. The weight lands harder because the warmth lowered the defenses first.

I have shared a stage with Sister Hazel. Their live performance has the same quality as the records, an openness and a generosity toward the audience that the music is built around. They play like they genuinely want the people in the room to feel something. That intention is audible and it shapes how those songs work.

What they embedded in my writing is the importance of the approach. How you bring the listener into the song before you ask them to go somewhere difficult with you. The melody, the production warmth, the accessible chord language, all of it is doing the work of creating the condition for the emotional content to land. You cannot skip the approach and go straight to the weight.

Sister Hazel appears in The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips and The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time.


MATCHBOX TWENTY — THE CONFESSIONAL IN COMMERCIAL FORM

Rob Thomas is one of the most skilled writers in the confessional pop-rock tradition. What he does with Matchbox Twenty is take genuinely vulnerable, genuinely personal emotional content and deliver it in a commercial form that reached an enormous audience without sanitizing what it was actually about.

That is a harder thing to do than it looks. The instinct when writing confessional material is either to stay in the art-rock corner where the subject matter is treated with appropriate obscurity and complexity, or to sand off the edges of the confession until it is palatable for radio. Thomas found a third path: precise, honest, specific emotional writing delivered in a musical form that met people where they were.

3 AM is a song about his mother's illness. Unwell is a song about mental health. These are not comfortable subjects dressed up in comfortable language. They are honest treatments of real subjects in a musical form that brought them to millions of people who needed to hear them.

What that taught me is that the commercial form and the honest content are not in opposition. You do not have to choose between reaching people and telling the truth. The combination is harder to execute than either option separately but it is the version worth attempting.

Matchbox Twenty appears in The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips, The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time, and The Best Rock Songs About Addiction and Recovery.


THE GASLIGHT ANTHEM — SPRINGSTEEN'S INHERITANCE PUT TO WORK

Brian Fallon absorbed the Springsteen tradition and did something genuine with it rather than simply paying tribute to it. The Gaslight Anthem's music has the American rock mythology of Springsteen but it lives in a different moment and speaks to a different generation.

What Fallon taught me is how to carry an influence without being consumed by it. How to take what someone did brilliantly and find what it means in your own voice and your own time rather than in theirs. His songs sound like they could only have been written by someone who grew up on Springsteen and simultaneously sound like they could only have been written by Brian Fallon. That combination is the goal of anyone working in a strong tradition.

The Gaslight Anthem appears in The Best Rock Songs About Addiction and Recovery and The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time.


COUNTING CROWS — EMOTIONAL PRECISION IN AN IMPRECISE GENRE

Adam Duritz writes with a specificity of emotional observation that is unusual in rock music. Not specificity of place or character in the Springsteen tradition, though some of that is present. Specificity of psychological state. The precise naming of what it feels like to want something that keeps receding. To be full of longing that does not attach cleanly to a particular object. To feel simultaneously too present and not present enough.

Mr. Jones is about wanting to be significant and the hollowness of that desire. A Long December is about the hope that things might get better without the assurance that they will. These are emotionally precise states that most songwriters gesture at without landing.

What Duritz embedded in my writing is the willingness to attempt precision about internal states rather than settling for the felt-sense approximation that most rock lyrics accept. When I write about identity or emotional lockdown or the weight of a decision I cannot take back, I am trying to land on the thing rather than near it. Counting Crows taught me that landing on it is possible and that the landing is worth the attempt.

Counting Crows appear in The Best Rock Songs for Road Trips, The Best Inspirational Rock Songs of All Time, and The Best Rock Songs About Addiction and Recovery.


WHAT ALL OF THEM SHARE

Every artist on this list has one thing in common underneath all the differences in sound and style and era.

They mean it.

The music they make carries the weight of being made by someone who cared about what they were trying to say and worked until they found the way to say it honestly. You can hear the caring in the records. Not sentimentality, not performance of feeling, but the actual weight of someone who needed to say something and found a form for it.

That is the thing I am trying to carry into every Tony Oso song. Not the sounds of any of these artists specifically. The commitment to meaning it that all of them share.

Your influences are going to be different from mine. The list of names that shaped what you hear and what you reach for will reflect who you are and where you came from and what you needed music to say. The work is to be honest about that list and then find what is yours within it.

Listen deeply. Steal nothing. Learn everything. Make what only you can make.

Tony Oso

Stream Tony Oso at tonyosomusic.com/music

Subscribe at tonyosomusic.com to stay connected to new music and the conversation about where it comes from and what it is for.

Leave a comment